By DAN MORAN via Reddit
My mother in law had her birthday in early July, and my wife Jill really didn’t want to miss it.
However, my in-laws live in Taylorville, Illinois, and we live in Southern California. None of us felt comfortable flying commercial due to COVID, so I volunteered to fly myself, Jill, and our two boys — Ethan, 10, and Alex, 6 — to Taylorville in my Sling TSi.
Jill was hesitant (she’s a nervous passenger, especially in any turbulence), but the destination was sufficiently tempting, so she agreed.
I did extensive planning, not just for the route, but for the setup of the airplane. I had plenty of useful load (my kids don’t weigh much, so it was just my skinny wife, our tiny kids, and my fat ass) for the four of us and our luggage, but for those of you unfamiliar with the Sling, there’s just not a ton of physical space to PUT the stuff. So, I bought compression tubes, packed everything as tightly as I could, and wedged bags into foot wells, under the kids’ seats, etc. Somehow, we made it work and were still about 200 pounds under gross with full fuel.
I had been having some intermittent maintenance issues before the flight (the Lane A warning light went on a few times in flight), so I let the guys at Sling have a look, and they assured me it was sorted out. [Narrator: It wasn’t.]
For those not familiar with the Rotax 915, it is a FADEC engine, and the lanes (A and B) refer to the two parallel control units. So, lanes are analogous to mags in that if you lose both, the engine stops, but they really are different animals.
Early on June 27, 2020, we set out!
Day 1: Zamperini Field Airport (KTOA) in Torrance, California, to Sedona Airport (KSEZ) in Sedona, Arizona. 2.7 hours on the hobbs, but about 30 minutes of that was on the ground at Torrance waiting for IFR release due to a marine layer.
This was a short and relatively uneventful flying day.
Sedona was nowhere near halfway to our destination, but the kids had never been to Sedona, and we wanted them to see it. So, we were there by late morning, went swimming, took a jeep tour, etc. Good times.
Notably, as I was on downwind into Sedona, my Lane A light came on again (not fun — landing at Sedona is a handful to begin with), but a quick reset resolved it. I called Sling after landing and they assured me it was just an erroneous sensor reading, and not to worry about it.
Day 2: Sedona to Liberal Mid-America Regional Airport (KLBL) in Liberal, Kansas. I had planned Sedona to Dalhart, Texas (KDHT) as our first leg of the day, but that turned out to be naively optimistic. The kids needed to pee, so I diverted to Double Eagle II Airport (KAEG) in Albuquerque, N.M. Had a quick bite, loaded back in, and continued east.
Lane A went off a few more times during this flight, and at this point it was becoming routine to just reset it.
Also, I had planned to climb up into the mid teens for better speed, but my 6-year-old refused to wear his O2 mask, so we had to settle for 11,500 and 15-20 kts slower than I would have liked.
After a few minutes of progress out of Albuquerque, turbulence went from mild to moderate/severe. Crossing the mountains in summer, that’s to be expected, but it sucked. My wife was white knuckling it, and the autopilot wasn’t able to keep up, so I switched it off and hand flew, trying to allow some deviations to keep it smooth.
After a long two-hour leg, we landed at Liberal. Winds were 30+ kts on the surface, but right down the runway, so no big deal. However, as soon as we climbed out, hats went flying, and my little guy was literally knocked over by the wind!
We went inside, got some drinks, and sat for a while. My wife was pretty shaken by this last leg, and we considered spending the night in Liberal. But a check of the forecast showed that the winds wouldn’t improve for a few days, at least, so it was either buy a house and move to Liberal or press on.
Thankfully, within five minutes of takeoff, conditions smoothed out, and stayed that way for the rest of the day.
We flew a long leg to Columbia Regional Airport (KCOU) in Columbia, Missouri, gassed up, and flew a short hop to Taylorville Municipal Airport (KTAZ) in Illinois, our final destination.
During these legs, Lane A would go off every so often, but I just muttered to myself and reset it.
We spent three lovely days relaxing with my in-laws, and on July 2, it was time to head back. The plan was to spend the night in Santa Fe, visit the Grand Canyon the following day, then head home.
But COVID threw another curve ball. New Mexico announced a 14-day quarantine for anyone arriving in the state, so Santa Fe was out.
We decided to try for a longer day of flying, and planned to spend the night in Page, Arizona. Alas, that was not meant to be.
Our first leg, Taylorville to Lee’s Summit Municipal Airport (KLXT) in Missouri was uneventful (other than a few more Lane A resets). Notably, my landing at KLXT was my 1,000th, so that was cool.
We got gas and continued to Hutchinson Regional Airport (KHUT) in Kansas, which we’d heard had a particularly good restaurant. On final into KHUT, my propellor controller (I have an Airmaster) suddenly started flashing three red lights (indicating an open circuit failure). I landed without incident, and we had lunch (not bad!).
With a full belly, I left my family in the AC, and headed out to the plane to see if I could figure out what went wrong. The guys at Sling were on the phone with me, and walked me through about 45 minutes of troubleshooting (in 105° heat, with 90% humidity, in direct sun), to no avail.
The prop controller was dead, and I would have to manually control the prop. Not easy with just the very imprecise switch I had in the panel, but so be it. I didn’t love the idea of flying all the way home that way though.
Fortunately, the Sling team came through for me again (they’re really great guys), and found a mechanic who could meet me at Lloyd Stearman Field (1K1) in Benton, Kansas, only a 20 minute flight away, to take a look. So away we went!
I landed at 1K1 and was really impressed with the field. They had a great restaurant (much better than KHUT in my opinion), and a really festive vibe going there. I waited on the ramp for the mechanic to arrive, and he showed up a few minutes later (he flew his Kitfox in from his farm — badass).
My family stayed in the restaurant and had some snacks while we took the cowling off and got to work. It turns out the brushes from the controller had separated from their solder points and were no longer effective. The mechanic and I begged a soldering iron off a local, patched it up, and I was back in business.
He warned me that this was a temporary fix and the brushes would need to be replaced, but this should get me home.
By this point, it was evening, and I knew we weren’t going any further. My wife found a hotel, grabbed an Uber with the kids, and headed out. I, however, had promised rides to a few locals who were eager to check out the Sling, so I spent about an hour doing that, then repositioned to Colonel James Jabara Airport (KAAO) in Wichita, (slightly closer to the hotel), and got a ride to meet them.
The next morning greeted us with stormy weather, as a cell passed over Wichita. So we took our time with breakfast, made our way to KAAO, and by the time we departed around 10:30, it was mostly cleared up. The prop controller was working 100%, and other than the persistent Lane A issue, all was well. We flew to Dalhart, Texas, for lunch.
I checked FIS-B before landing, and the way ahead looked good. But in the hour or so it took us to eat, a line of storms had popped up in Eastern New Mexico. We took off out of KDHT, and within a few minutes thought better of it and returned to KDHT.
We spent about two hours on the ground hoping the storms would dissipate, but they just kept building. So, I made a new plan: We would head south towards Midland, then turn west to El Paso. This would take us south of the weather, and let us make at least some westward progress.
However, the weather wasn’t done with us yet. We took off into some of the worst turbulence I’ve experienced in my flying career. My wife was turning green and clutching a barf bag (which she thankfully didn’t wind up using). Notably, my kids were watching movies on their tablets and couldn’t have cared less, but my poor wife just couldn’t take it.
So, after just a few minutes, I turned east and landed at Rick Husband Amarillo International Airport (KAMA) in Amarillo, Texas, for the night. We had a very colorful dinner at the Big Texan Steak Ranch (for the uninitiated, it’s an experience!), and went to bed.
The next day (the 4th of July, for those keeping track), we woke up to calm winds and no weather issues in our path. I was confident we’d make it home at last. We still didn’t want to try our luck with New Mexico, so we flew a long leg to Holbrook Municipal Airport (P14) in Holbrook, Arizona, and fueled up. From there, it was a short hop back to Sedona for some awesome lunch (the restaurant there is terrific). Now we just had one leg left and we’d be back home at Torrance!
Of course, by this point in the trip I’d given up counting how many times I’d reset Lane A in flight, and planned to give the Sling guys a piece of my mind about it on Monday. But for now, I figured we’d be fine to get home. [Narrator: They weren’t.]
We took off into bumpy skies (no surprise in Arizona in July!), and climbed up to 12,500 looking for smoother air. As we came across the Colorado river, I could feel home coming into range.
However, I could also feel just the slightest hint of roughness in the engine. I obsessively checked all the instruments, and everything was solidly in the green, so I figured it must be jitters. [Narrator: It wasn’t].
After about 10 minutes of this, guess what? The Lane A light comes on again. This time, though, it was accompanied by a loud surging of the engine and a partial loss of power. I reset it, and everything went back to normal — except my wife, who LOST HER SHIT. She panicked, demanding to know what was going on.
Of course, at this point I had no idea. All the gauges were reading normal. I knew we had 12,500 feet of altitude and were going to be fine even if the engine quit, but there was no way to communicate that to my hysterical wife. Before I could really even begin to figure it out, 30 seconds later, it happened again. Lane A light, surging engine, power loss, resolved by reset.
That was enough for me — I wanted the plane on the ground. So, I discovered Twentynine Palms Airport (KTNP) in California, was the nearest airport, pointed at it, and began dropping altitude as rapidly as I could with my kids’ sensitive ears.
A few minutes later, we made an uneventful landing at KTNP. It was 110° in the California desert, and the field was deserted. I hopped out, spent about five minutes yelling and swearing, and then tried to get my bearings.
Thankfully, there was a small pilot’s lounge that was air conditioned. I parked the family there, called a friend to come pick us up (at this point, we’re only a 2.5-hour drive from home), and tried to get the Sling guys on the phone again. Of course, it was the 4th of July, so they weren’t available. Fair enough.
We unloaded the plane, waited for our ride (if not for that air conditioned room, it could have been a massive problem, but we did have the room, so it was just boring), and drove home.
On Monday, July 6, the guys from Sling flew to Twentynine Palms, picked up the plane, and nursed it back to Torrance. On their return flight, the prop controller failed again (the mechanic at 1K1 warned me it was a temporary fix!), and of course Lane A continued to misbehave. They still have the plane now, and have sworn to get to the bottom of any and all issues and return it at 100%.
UPDATE: The plane is now fixed. There was a sensor mounted to a bracket, which somehow got bent a bit. When that happened, a slightly overlong screw through the bracket touched the component next to the engine control unit, which created a short. Just a crazy thing. Bad luck.
So, it was a huge adventure, extremely rewarding, and a great educational experience for me. It was also an object lesson in normalization of deviation.
In retrospect, of course I regret taking their word for it that Lane A was “just a sensor issue,” but at the time, I had no way of knowing otherwise, and they are the experts! So I’m really not sure what I would do differently.
I am pleased with how I handled the maintenance issues and “emergency” (it wasn’t really an emergency, but it could have become one).
Would I do it again? Absolutely.
Would my wife? The jury is still out.
Total flight time: 24.4 hours.
California to Illinois
Depart | Arrive | Hours |
---|---|---|
KTOA | KSEZ | 2.7 |
KSEZ | KAEG | 1.9 |
KAEG | KLBL | 2.3 |
KLBL | KCOU | 2.9 |
KCOU | KTAZ | 1.2 |
11.0 |
Illinois to California
Depart | Arrive | Hours |
---|---|---|
KTAZ | KLXT | 1.4 |
KLXT | KHUT | 1.4 |
KHUT | 1K1 | 0.7 |
1K1 | Local | 0.6 |
1K1 | KAAO | 0.2 |
KAAO | KDHT | 2.1 |
KDHT | Local | 0.4 |
KDHT | KAMA | 0.9 |
KAMA | P14 | 3.2 |
P14 | KSEZ | 0.8 |
KSEZ | KTNP | 1.7 |
HTNP | Home (via car) | 2.5* |
* not included in total | 13.4 |
Well… I for one throughly enjoyed the story. And I was enlightened by it too. Thank you so much for writing it and taking a risk to share if publicly! And as for the self-righteous, self-important AH’s who can’t wait to jump in and second guess the crap out of the author to make themselves feel superior, you all can suck it. Do us all a favor and hold your (friendly) fire on your fellow pilots! Instead, thank them for sharing their experiences, learn what you can, and enjoy the read. I did. If it’s not your cup of tea, move on. That’s fine too. But trashing pilots from the safety of your Lazyboy for sharing their flying experiences is cowardly and counterproductive. Share flying experiences, pilots! Please. Ignore the critics who are just pooping in the punchbowl.
Thanks. I appreciate it. (I’m the author!)
Great story. I don’t agree with the detractor comments. Most have probably never flown more than a couple of hours from their home airport. The Rotax is a fine engine and there are no “dime store parts” on it. I fly behind a continental and a Jabiru engine in my two planes. Someday I hope to add a Rotax to my fleet.
Thanks for the support. I appreciate it!
I mean, I certainly get the issue – and admitted asuch in the article. The real world is a messy place!
Only one positive comment among the lot. It all really depends on the commenters personal traits wether your going to find faults or hear of a grand adventure for the family and the pilot.
I sure wish I was in the position to be an aircraft owner and set out on a GA family vacation.
Not sure I’d write about it for y’all to pick apart.
I’ll fly with you anytime. What an adventure!
Thanks! If you’re ever near TOA, let me know!
I think you guys need to chill out a little. That was a great story and sometimes things just happen while flying. I think he did pretty damn good. He researched, planned, and made decisions based on that research. I’ve logged over 10,000 hours in single engine aircraft so believe me when I say I’ve experienced about everything that can be thrown at me in a single. You guys need to remember that even if an aircraft has a perfect bill of health, it does not mean it is 100% reliable, it’s just AIRWORTHY.
That being said, when you are thrown a curve sometimes you have to act and think for yourself, use whatever is available to safely fly the aircraft, and to hell with what some little piece of paper says, that’s why it is called Pilot-In-Command. Sure you can sit on your couch and make judgements on what someone “should” have done, but a pilot is never given that luxury when things are going wrong, even when the problem is the result of a mechanic giving the “go-ahead” for a flight. Ask yourself how many times you have had to rely on the advice of a mechanic when an indicator is telling you opposite? If you’ve never had to nurse an aircraft or fly one that has an impending problem then YOU HAVE NOT FLOWN ENOUGH and shouldn’t judge someone who is sharing their experience. I’ve taken my family on several cross country flights, and know the accomplishment he felt once home, very rewarding! I am sure he, like myself, would never knowingly endanger his family in any way, and has had to rely on the advice of those who support aircraft operation, i.e. mechanics! So, for you self-appointed, holier-than-thow, and judge-mental uber pilots who talk more about flying than actually fly…stay home and on the ground where you can keep convincing those around you and yourself of how perfect you are. The skies, other pilots and the regulating authorities will be grateful, and maybe other pilots will share their stories like this without the fear of being criticized….Great story man
Thanks – I appreciate it. Normalization of deviance is a real issue, but I think I did it (mostly) right. Helluva trip, that’s for sure.
Oh, and my wife has flown again with me since! If she trusts me, that’s the highest bar imaginable.
The thing that struck me was trying to avoid covid by staying out of an airliner and airports. Arguably, all the restaurants, jeep rides, airport personnel, hotels, mechanics and so forth presented more exposure than simply getting on a 737 and getting there (but less fun for sure).
Trust me, that occured to us. But we figured one set of risks was easier to manage than the other. And the reward side on that risk/reward calculation looks very different!
Seems as though get home itis prevailed over safety several times. On a trip from DVT to Elm we flew part of this route. Since my wife was willing to fly with me she completed the pinch hitter course, and always had go or no go rights, using it only once in 22 years of flying. We spent the night in Silver City, New Mexico waiting out a large storm. I should have RONed in ELP, as there is some of the best mexican food any where there, and a motel right on the airport. Safety is NEVER a mistake.
Get Home-itis prevailed over good judgement several times. Sounds like you need more safety training. On one flight from DVT to ELM I flew along part of the route shown here. Since my wife was willing to fly with me even though she completed the pinch hitter course she always had go-nogo rights, but in 20 years of lying she only used it once. We spent the night in Silver City New Mexico waiting out a rather large storm.
I’d recommending this guy jacking his Sling TSi up and driving a new one in under it, perhaps a Cessna 182, before he kills himself and his family? And he wonders why his wife is a white knuckle flier??
Actually, I enjoyed the story. My wife is a reluctant flyer but she did join me for a flight from Washington State to Virginia in our Maule. I found it interesting to learn how others have dealt with nervous passengers in less than ideal conditions. I didn’t have any mechanical or electrical issues, but did have weather to contend with. I’ve also been curious about the Sling aircraft. On paper it seems under powered for a 4 seater, but this story indicated it was able to climb well within 200 pounds of gross weight. I was surprised. I’m also glad I’m flying a tube and rag airplane with no complicated systems to deal with. I’ve always considered FADEC as something for the expensive airplane club. I’ll stick with plain and simple for my personal flying machine, even if it is slow.
Agreed…plain and simple MOST of the time gets the job done .
It’s an incredible machine, really. It does so much with so little.
Worse? The guy was flying with KNOWN engine problems…he put himself and family at known risk.
Typo Error on your route leaving KTOA – You did not go to KSEA (Seattle Tacoma); – SHB KSEZ.
The kids need to pee, the wife is a nervous wreck, and the dime store ignition system keeps breaking. Why on earth would someone submit inane stuff like this for the public to read? Is this suppose to be informative? Educational? Funny? I don’t get it.
Just what I was thinking as I read his story. And Rotax are not made with dime store parts. If he had any foresight, he would have enrolled his wife in a pitch hitter course before the flight.
You’re right. You don’t get it.
I was hoping others would benefit from my experience, and learn from my mistakes. That’s how pilots should help each other.