This is an excerpt from a report made to the Aviation Safety Reporting System. The narrative is written by the pilot, rather than FAA or NTSB officials. To maintain anonymity, many details, such as aircraft model or airport, are often scrubbed from the reports.
I was instructing a student pilot on his second lesson after a two-week gap from the first one.
We started the aircraft and received a clearance to the active runway and began our taxi.
The winds were strong, but not uncontrollable, but my student had difficulty maintaining the taxiway centerline. On a larger deviation to the left, my student reacted by putting in an abrupt full right rudder deflection and applied brake.
I declared “my controls” and my student froze on the controls and failed to follow procedure. By the time I was able to get him to respond, the aircraft was past the taxiway edge, and the right main gear struck the light.
At this point we notified Tower, completed a circuit on the taxiway to verify function, and took the aircraft back to the ramp for inspection by the mechanic. The mechanic verified the dent, inspected for any further damage, and approved the aircraft for continued operation. A flight was then commenced without incident.
The training environment brings a lot of unusual reactions to stress, and in the future I will do a better job of re-emphasizing the positive exchange of controls in these early lessons, especially when potentially challenging winds exist.
Primary Problem: Human Factors
ACN: 1886030
Of course it’s CYA. That’s what ASRS is designed for. I’ve got to believe that whatever happened here was inadvertent, so everyone gets to discuss and learn and he gets relief from enforcement. I would hope the student filed an ASRS report as well.
Hmmm, this story does not pass the smell test for me.
There are two brakes, and applying the left, equalling both, at safe taxi speeds would have stopped the airplane before it left the pavement. Maybe a student instructor, as well as a student pilot. Looks like the instructor was applying the CYA here.
I’m tented to agree with You, Tim.
Yes, and with strong winds on the second lesson, maybe the instructor should have handled all ground operations.